Letter to the Editor
Published in this mornings Globe and Mail. For those unfamiliar with the story, Paul Coffin defrauded the government of $1.5 million, was found guilty and was sentenced to repay two thirds of the money, to be home by 9pm for two years and to go on a speaking tour lecturing about business ethics.
Does deterrence work?
Source: GAM - Globe & Mail
Sep 30 03:55
Page: A22
Section: Letter to the Editor
Byline: ADAM SCOTT, Ottawa
Anthony Westell is wrong about why deterrence rarely works (Why
We Shouldn't Put A Nail In This Coffin -- Sept. 29). It has
nothing to do with criminals' confidence that they will not
be caught.
Criminal masterminds make up a very small portion of Canada's
felons. Most crimes are committed either with no forethought
or by people with nothing to lose. Criminals acting under the
influence of alcohol, drugs, mental disorder or extreme emotions
are unlikely to be deterred by the thought of harsh
sentences.
Similarly, those who have been to jail often or whose life outside
of jail is not measurably worse than life on the inside are
less likely to care about the length of their sentence.
Wealthy, well-educated businessmen with nice homes and loving
families are quite capable of forethought and have a lot to
lose. To my mind, they seem the most likely group to be deterred
from crime by harsh sentences. Paul Coffin's case is one of
the few where I see value in using a jail sentence as a
deterrent.
Does deterrence work?
Source: GAM - Globe & Mail
Sep 30 03:55
Page: A22
Section: Letter to the Editor
Byline: ADAM SCOTT, Ottawa
Anthony Westell is wrong about why deterrence rarely works (Why
We Shouldn't Put A Nail In This Coffin -- Sept. 29). It has
nothing to do with criminals' confidence that they will not
be caught.
Criminal masterminds make up a very small portion of Canada's
felons. Most crimes are committed either with no forethought
or by people with nothing to lose. Criminals acting under the
influence of alcohol, drugs, mental disorder or extreme emotions
are unlikely to be deterred by the thought of harsh
sentences.
Similarly, those who have been to jail often or whose life outside
of jail is not measurably worse than life on the inside are
less likely to care about the length of their sentence.
Wealthy, well-educated businessmen with nice homes and loving
families are quite capable of forethought and have a lot to
lose. To my mind, they seem the most likely group to be deterred
from crime by harsh sentences. Paul Coffin's case is one of
the few where I see value in using a jail sentence as a
deterrent.
